Home » Peanut Butter Cookies
Daryl Ehrman

Daryl Ehrman

Registered Dietitian Nutritionist · All Posts

Peanut Butter Cookies

This peanut butter cookie recipe can be used in a number of ways. I love King Arthur’s proportions for a nice, stiff workable dough. I’ve broken down these Peanut Butter Cookies to 2 ways, as described below. OPTION 1: I grew up eating those peanut butter blossom cookies with the Hershey kiss in the middle.…

This peanut butter cookie recipe can be used in a number of ways. I love King Arthur’s proportions for a nice, stiff workable dough. I’ve broken down these Peanut Butter Cookies to 2 ways, as described below.

OPTION 1: I grew up eating those peanut butter blossom cookies with the Hershey kiss in the middle. Since I am an adult with a choice now, I chopped up a leftover Toblerone bar and some Kinder Bueno minis to press in the middle for a burst of chocolate. A little more gourmet than the kisses.

OPTION 2: the classic version: pressed down in a crosshatch pattern with the tines of a fork. 

These cookies are especially delicious packed for lunch, to work, school, on a hike, to the beach…. Goes well with a glass of cold milk, a cup of tea or coffee. Pairs beautifully with a sliced tart green apple or a pear as a snack. They freeze nicely for longer storing.

Check out the video recipe above on YouTube

Ingredients:

113 g butter, unsalted

90 g white granulated sugar

106 g packed brown sugar (I used dark)

1 egg

1 tsp vanilla extract

200 g peanut butter (smooth or crunchy, store brand works great)

180 g TIP 550/all-purpose flour

1 tsp baking soda

½ tsp salt

Optional: chocolate candy, split into pieces, kinder bueno minis cut in half 

(I think whatever chocolate you like that’s melty will do well here!)

Instructions:

1.) Preheat oven to 176 degrees C/350 degrees F

2.) Combine butter, granulated sugar, brown sugar, egg, vanilla, peanut butter and cream together until combined and fluffy.

3.) Mix the dry ingredients: Grab another bowl and mix the dry ingredients well: flour, baking soda and salt.

4.) Combined the dry and the wet: Gradually mix the drys into the wets until a still dough forms.

5.) Weigh out 25 g balls of dough, (TB amounts, you can also use a cookie scoop if you have) for uniform-sized cookies.

6.) Press the slice of chocolate candy into the middle of the cookie. Or, press down to make the crosshatch pattern with a fork.

7.) Bake (about 6 per tray w/ space between) for 12-15 minutes or slightly brown around the edges.

Enjoy your Peanut Butter Cookies!

Get This Delivered to Your Inbox!
Love this? Enter your email below and I’ll send you the article so you can access anytime!

Book your personal consultation now

Copyright © 2026 Nourish with Daryl